45 years, 9 months, 1 day ago.
|Venue||Rainbow Theatre, London|
|Track #||Track Name||
|1.1||Eleventh Earl Of Mar|
|1.3||Robbery, Assault & Battery|
|1.4||Your Own Special Way|
|1.6||One For The vine|
|1.7||Firth Of Fifth|
|1.8||All In A Mouse's Night|
|2.2||I Know What I Like|
|2.3||Dance On A Volcano / Drum Duet|
|2.5||The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway / The Musical Box|| |
Total Running Time :
This version is for me better than the TM Production one!!!!!!!!!!
I agree with padoubibi... I was amazed to discover this hidden recording, I love 1977 sets, and when I've played it, wow, such a pleasure! Surely it's a good "A", an average, quite clean soundboard of that era, ok, some flaws, some noises, but all ordinary, almost like or better than Earl's Court beloved tapes. So, when I saw the TM release, trusting the brand, I've taken it, hoping to find a good "rework" done on a pretty good source... but, with all the THANKFUL respect to (past, present and future) Tom's job, I've found the remastered version muddy, dead in the high frequencies, less punchy with an untasty digital ambience added.
That's my honest opinion... If I have to choose one version, that raw one sound definitively better.
This is the source recording that was used for the TM remaster. Naturally, it appears as if there were more high frequencies, but this impression comes from the reduced level of basses (typical for soundboard recordings). In fact, the remaster's frequency spectrum is quite close to Seconds Out. It was my aim to use the official recording as reference in sound. Adding artificial reverb (Lexicon 960L) is a matter of taste, no doubt. But I don't like the absence of it. A proper live recording needs room. This recording like most soundboards has not enough for my taste. [tom]
I like this one, and I like the TM version too.
I've listened to all again, so...
I agree with your point of wiew Tom, the sound should be considered in his whole spectrum, and certainly, in this case, you've gained body in the bottom, reaching a "softer" and "cleaner" impact. The "ambience" question is a personal matter, the raw soundboards sound usually too much dry, affecting the straight-connected instruments with no reverb in the mix (like Tony's RMI and ARP Pro Soloist, definitively cheesy without a room); but adding reverb to the whole mix of a poor-dynamic support like those kind of tape cassettes recording, always result in a little loss of punch with a blurrier sound. But that's not a rule. Some tracks, like "One For The Vine" and "Your Own Special Way" are really enjoyable on the remaster, especially in the quieter points (great denoising job!); some other, when the band is up on their notes, are better and sharper on the raw one. I like to have both versions (as usual), the remaster sounds really good on my Stax and Beyer Headphones, the other is better on my JBL's speaker with a high volume; so, thank you SO much again Tom for your work, and for all who have to choose a version, follow your taste, they're both great and they're both an "A", without a doubt. G. [Gigio67]
Add recording comments (Registered users only)
Add show memories (Registered users only)
|Users owning this recording (including quality rating)|
|Simon_Funnell (A), Matt McMad, Jesper Moonen, wbeens (A), Chiffi_Argentina, davebriddon, casey1942, Slipperman, CaptainRansid (A), dbrunnerwi, Si_M (A), meek, LaTortue, speedy (A), joeydrums, dnhartle, jvkl (A), vocaltange, SimonH, Nahuel_Argentina, squonk100 (A), andykeego (A), hecko, David35 (A), PaulHarald, lamb79 (A), Gigio67 (A), fosco (A), Ecki, mlpain24, padoubibi (A), cirrus (A), patanjali, Jangley, rudystammer, vanbijo, jackson, MetalMike (A), Dorsetbay (A), maurirhs, fuelesfan, Face-Value (A), Schniwupo42 (A), Squonkendos, hookstone, zervin (A)|
Add me | Remove me (Registered users only)
03-Jan-1977 Rainbow Theatre, London - Live In London
03-Jan-1977 Rainbow Theatre, London - Live In Rainbow Theatre
03-Jan-1977 Rainbow Theatre, London
|Artwork for this date|
* Quality rating average from 19 cast votes.
Total Page views : 39
showdetails version # 1.0.10 - 6814